Skip to content
Hypothetical committee report · Q3 2026

Inside a quarterly retirement plan committee meeting

$48 million manufacturing 401(k) plan · Committee meeting of September 30, 2026

Illustrative case prepared by Aperture. The plan, bids, investment results and committee decisions are fictional.

Chair’s briefing

Three decisions for this meeting

Investments. Put the core bond fund on watch and request evidence on the manager transition before December.

Employee education. Approve two enrollment sessions for the night shift and check participation 60 days later.

Payroll readiness. Test rehire records before the January conversion and name the person who will reconcile the first two files.

Two investment decisions for the committee

Active core bond fund · place on watch

The fund holds $4.8 million. Its annualized net return trailed the plan’s broad U.S. bond benchmark by 0.7 percentage points over three years and 0.2 points over five. The lead manager left in June. Most of the measured shortfall predates the departure, so the committee needs separate answers on results and succession. Ask for attribution by duration, sector and security selection, plus the successor’s decision authority. Compare with the mandate in the investment policy before the December meeting.

Target-date series · retain and investigate fit

The default series holds $26.4 million, or 55% of plan assets. Its retirement-year portfolio holds 48% in equities. The committee lacks withdrawal data showing whether retiring employees typically leave their money in the plan. Request distributions by age and time since separation before deciding whether the glide path still fits the workforce.

Where employees need support

Enrollment · reach the night shift

Of 600 eligible employees, 480 contribute (80%). Day-shift participation is 360 of 420 eligible employees (86%), versus 120 of 180 on nights (67%). Existing enrollment meetings take place during the day. HR will pilot two night-shift sessions and compare new enrollments after 60 days, tracking new hires separately. The employer matches the first 4% of pay dollar for dollar. Of the 480 contributors, 96 save below that threshold. HR will track match uptake separately from new enrollments.

Payroll · test rehire records first

Service logs show eight payroll exceptions in six months. Six involved rehires. Before the conversion, payroll will test rehire dates, deferral elections and match calculations against ten sample records and reconcile the first two production files with the recordkeeper.

What goes in the minutes

Decision entered in the hypothetical minutes. The committee placed the core bond fund on watch, retained the default series pending workforce data, approved night-shift enrollment outreach, and assigned payroll testing to the payroll lead. Finance may negotiate renewal terms and return them for a separate decision.

Follow-up calendar

October 15 · Finance director
Obtain a written fee guarantee, service commitments and termination terms. Return any unresolved contract item to the chair before signature.
October 30 · HR and payroll leads
Report test-file discrepancies and assign corrections. Establish a night-shift enrollment baseline and schedule both sessions.
60 days after outreach · HR lead
Compare enrollment and full-match uptake with the baseline by shift. Separate new hires and report changes in the eligible population before interpreting results.
December 10 · Advisor and committee
Review bond attribution, succession and retirement withdrawals. Record the rationale for retaining or replacing the fund and set the next monitoring date.
After the January conversion · Payroll lead
Reconcile deductions and match amounts for the first two payrolls. Give the chair an exception log with owners and resolution dates.
Appendix · Recordkeeper renewal and fee analysis

Finance will seek a one-year renewal, written service commitments, and termination terms. Bring the bids back if the incumbent declines or the conversion fee is waived.

The incumbent offered a lower renewal price. Finance compared that offer with the challenger using the same 600 billable accounts, investment mix, payroll support and two onsite education sessions. Both bids assume zero revenue sharing.

Employer cash outlay, including conversion
Time horizonRenewSwitchCost of switching vs. renewing
Year one$87,000$96,000$9,000 more
30 months$217,500$217,500Break-even
Three years$261,000$258,000$3,000 less

The challenger charges $81,000 a year plus $15,000 to convert. Against the $87,000 renewal, annual savings of $6,000 recover the conversion charge in 2½ years. These projections hold pricing and headcount constant beyond the proposed one-year term. Internal labor is excluded. More than $3,000 of additional staff time would erase the three-year savings.

View the full fee breakdown, including investment expenses
Annual cost at $48 million in assets
Cost componentTodayRenewalChallenger
Recordkeeping$48,000$39,000$30,000
Payroll support and onsite educationIncludedIncluded$3,000
Third-party administration$12,000$12,000$12,000
Advisory services$36,000$36,000$36,000
Investment expenses¹$86,400$86,400$86,400
Total recurring cost$182,400$173,400$167,400

¹ At an assumed asset-weighted expense ratio of 0.18%. Investment expenses are borne through fund returns. The employer pays the other listed costs. Balances and headcount are held constant. The bids illustrate negotiated prices for this case and provide no market percentile.

Illustrative inputs: quarter-end census, provider fee schedules and bids for 600 billable accounts, investment factsheets, and six months of service logs. Account count includes 120 former employees with balances. Participation figures use current eligible employees.

Explore a review of your plan